Monitoring

Monitoring

Monitoring the implementation of Grid Connection Codes

Image
Monitoring graph

ACER, together with the European Network of Transmission System Operators (ENTSO-E), oversees the implementation of the Grid Connection Network Codes to ensure they promote market integration, prevent discrimination, encourage effective competition, and contribute to the efficient functioning of the European electricity markets.

To do so, ACER issues implementation monitoring reports on the status of every Term, Condition, or Methodology (TCM), and provides continuous oversight of specific implementation aspects (e.g., if national derogation decisions apply, lifting specific obligations from the network code).

Monitoring

Derogations monitoring

ACER  monitors the implementation of the RfG RegulationDCC Regulation, and HVDC Regulation and their national derogation decisions.

In case a justification is missing, ACER may issue a reasoned recommendation to a regulatory authority to revoke the derogation.​​

The RECORD tool

​NRAs must maintain a register of all derogations they have granted (or refused) and provide ACER with an updated register at least once every six months. ACER then monitors and analyses the information provided.

ACER’s RECORD tool provides a centralised register where regulatory and other relevant authorities can log all derogation and revocation decisions. The tool also serves as a single source of information for stakeholders wishing to access derogation criteria as defined by the NRAs or the Member States’ relevant authorities and their decisions.​

Before submitting information on the RECORD tool, relevant authorities need to register on the AEGIS portal. Access the manual for registered RECORD users.

Any questions on the derogation criteria or collection process? Contact: electricity(at)acer.europa.eu​

​Any questions on the RECORD tool or AEGIS? Write to: aegis.admin(at)acer.europa.eu

Monitoring

ACER Reporting

​RfG

​DCC

​HVDC

October 2017: 1st Implementation Monitoring Report of the Network Code on Requirements for Grid Connection Generators​. ​

August 2018: 1st Implementation Monitoring Report of the Network Code on Demand Connection and of the Network Code on requirements for grid connection of high voltage direct current systems and direct current-connected power park modules.

November 2019: 2nd Implementation Monitoring Report of the Network Code on Requirements for Grid Connection of Generators.

​​


​December 2020: 3rd Implementation Monitoring Report of the Network Code on Requirements for Grid Connection of Generators.

​December 2020: 2nd Implementation Monitoring Report of the Network Code on Demand and HVDC Connections.

November 2021: follow-up Report on Monitoring the Implementation of the Grid Connection Network Codes.

The document provides an updated analysis of the compliance issues identified in previous monitoring exercises by clustering them in seven topics concerning NC RfG and seven topics concerning NC DC and NC HVDC, including:

  • the approval of the requirements of general applications, and
  • the presence of discrepancies (at national level) compared to the values in the corresponding Network Codes.
Documents

See Also

Implementation

Acer image

​As the Regulations do not foresee approvals by more than one regulatory authority, the Agency will not be asked to adopt decisions when regulatory authorities cannot agree on terms, conditions and methodologies.​

RfG Implementation​

 

The Agency monitors the procedure of granting derogations from one or more provisions of the RfG Regulation.

The relevant regulatory authority decides which power-generating modules should be classified as an emerging technology. Any regulatory authority of the relevant synchronous area may request a prior opinion from the Agency, which shall be issued within three months after receiving the request. The decision of the relevant regulatory authority shall then take into account the Agency's opinion.

All regulatory authorities of a synchronous area may also decide in a coordinated manner to withdraw a classification as an emerging technology. Also in this case, the regulatory authorities of the synchronous area concerned may request a prior opinion from the Agency, which shall be issued within three months. Where applicable, the coordinated decision of the regulatory authorities shall take into account ACER's opinion.

Find out more on how national regulatory authorities implemented the transitional arrangements for emerging technologies in the Implementation Monitoring Report of the Network Code on Requirements for Grid Connection of Generators

The accumulated sales of power-generating modules classified as emerging technology are also made available by the national regulatory authorities every two months.

RfG Implementation​​
Documents

​The Agency monitors the procedure of granting derogations from one or more provisions of the DCC Regulation. The Agency may issue a reasoned recommendation to a regulatory authority to revoke a derogation, in case justification is missing.​

The Agency monitors the procedure of granting derogations from one or more provisions of the HVD​C Regulation. The Agency may issue a reasoned recommendation to a regulatory authority to revoke a derogation, in case justification is missing.​​

DCC Implementation
HVDC Implementation
See Also

Connection Codes

Connection Codes

Ensuring system security and sound technical evolution

Image
powerlines

Network codes are binding rules that govern electricity networks' connection requirements in an effective and transparent manner. They were established in 2009 by the EU Regulation on conditions for access to the network for cross-border exchanges in electricity  and recast in 2019 by the Regulation on the internal market for electricity. In 2023, ACER proposed amendments to two of the grid connection codes to the European Commission.

The codes are crucial for ensuring the safety of system operation and the efficiency of the European Union's power grid. ​

Connection Codes

Grid Connection Codes

Grid connection refers to all the subjects establishing and maintaining a physical connection between the transmission and/or distribution grids and the grid users.  

Grid connection, or network connection, is one of the areas regulated by the specific network codes. These rules aim to develop a harmonised electricity grid connection regime, as well as efficient and secure operations. This is particularly important in view of the integration of an increasing share of sources of renewable energy in the system. European rules on grid connection also ensure a fair competition in the electricity market, and facilitate the electricity trade across the Union.

Three network codes on grid connection have been developed:

  • The Network Code on requirements for grid connection of generators (RfG Regulation) establishes common standards that generators must respect to connect to the grid.

  • The Network Code on demand connection (DCC Regulation) sets up harmonised requirements that demand facilities must respect to connect to the grid. 

  • The Network Code on requirements for grid connection of high voltage direct current systems (HVDC Regulation) covers the definition of harmonised standards for direct current (DC) connections.​​​

See Also

Risk preparedness

acer image

​​​​​The Risk Preparedness Regulation introduces important rules for the cooperation between Member States with the aim to prevent, prepare for, and manage electricity crises. It also establishes common provisions for risk assessment, risk preparedness plans, managing electricity crises, evaluation and monitoring.

Each Member State's competent authority must establish a risk-preparedness plan, based on the regional and national electricity crisis scenarios. This plan consists of national, regional and where applicable, bilateral measures planned or taken to prevent, prepare for and mitigate electricity crises.

The Regulation foresees the adoption of two methodologies during the course of 2020:

  • methodology for identifying regional electricity crisis scenarios

  • methodology for short-term and seasonal adequacy assessment.

Enhancing Member States' cooperation
Documents

In the interest of EU electricity security of supply, EU law requires ENTSO-E to identify the most relevant regional electricity crisis scenarios (following a methodology approved by ACER). The methodology is required to consider system adequacy, system security and fuel security. It also must include an analysis of all relevant national and regional circumstances, simulations of simultaneous electricity crisis scenarios, ranking of risks, as well as probability and principles on how to handle sensitive information in a transparent manner.

Following extensive consultation, including a (2019) ENTSO-E public consultation a (2020) ACER public consultation and the consultation with the Electricity Coordination Group, ACER published (6 March 2020) its Decision on the methodology for identifying regional electricity crisis scenarios. Access the methodology​.

On 8 March 2024, ACER issued its Decision on the amendment  to the methodology for identifying regional electricity crisis scenarios. This ACER Decision follows extensive public consultations by ENTSO-E (in Spring and Autumn 2023), by ACER with the Electricity Coordination Group (composed only of the Member States' representatives), NRAs and ENTSO-E. The improved methodology reflects amendments that ACER deems necessary to ENTSO-E’s proposal (submitted on 8 January 2024).

​ENTSO-E must submit to ACER a proposal for a methodology assessing seasonal an​​d short-term adequacy (monthly, week-ahead to at least day-ahead adequacy). The proposal must cover at least the probability of a transmission capacity outage, the probability of an unplanned power plants' outage, severe weather conditions, variable demand, variable generation from renewable sources, as well as the probability of occurrence of a single or simultaneous electricity crises.

Action 1: From July to October 2019, ENTSO-E has conducted a public consultation on its proposal for a methodology for short-term and seasonal adequacy assessment.  

Action 2: On 6 January 2020, ENTSO-E submitted the proposal to ACER. Find out more about the ENTSO-E proposal and the Explanatory document accompanying the document.

Action 3: On 6 January 2020, ACER opened a public consultation for all stakeholders on ENTSO-E proposal.

Action 4: ACER is expected to consult the proposal with the ECG, in its formation composed only of Member States' representatives.

Action 5: Within two months following the receipt of the proposal, ACER is expected to approve or amend it.

Action 6: On 6 March 2020, ACER issued the Decision on the methodology for short-term and seasonal adequacy assessments. Access the methodology​.

Methodology for identifying regional electricity crisis scenarios
Methodology for short-term and seasonal adequacy assessment
See Also

An enhanced role for ACER

acer image

The revised ACER Regulation introduces additional tasks for ACER, further to the coordination of national energy regulatory authorities (NRAs). ​​The new set of rules provides ACER with new responsibilities connected with cross-border cooperation, which could, if uncoordinated, lead to difficulties in the internal energy market.

The Regulation defines ACER's objectives and tasks, which include:

ACER will have the regulatory oversight of Regional Coordination Centres (RCCs), which will play an important role for the coordination of transmission system operators, strengthening ACER's decision-making power with respect to cross-border issues.

ACER's role in monitoring and contributing to the implementation of the network codes and guidelines has also been strengthened. ACER will have a role in reviewing the draft network codes, including chec​​​​​​king for compliance with ACER's non-binding framework guidelines, as well as amending the draft before recommending it for adoption to the Commission.

The role of ACER in approving and amending EU-wide terms and conditions and methodologies has also been reinforced.

ACER is now responsible for taking a decision where the competent regulatory authorities do not agree on terms and conditions or methodologies for the implementation of new network codes and guidelines adopted after 4 July 2019.​​

Find out more about ACER’s monitoring of the Regional Coordination Centres.

New tasks and responsibilities
Documents
See Also

New Electricity Regulation

New Electricity Regulation

Adapting to new emerging market realities

​​The new Electricity Regulation aims to adapt the existing market rules to new emerging market realities.

The new Regulation provides a set of fundamental principles for well-functioning, integrated electricity markets.

It includes general rules for the electricity market and covers in detail network access and congestion management, resource adequacy, transmission system operators, distribution system operators, as well as network codes and guidelines.​

New Electricity Regulation

The Regional Coordination Centres and the implementation of system operation regions

Image
Electricity transmission pillars, national development plans

The new Electricity Regulation foresees the establishment of Regional Coordination Centres (RCCs), replacing the regional security coordinators established by the System Operation Guideline

Their tasks include: 

  • supporting the consistency assessment of transmission system operators' defence and restoration plans, ensuring an effective application of the Emergency and Restoration Network Code's procedure

  • supporting the coordination and optimisation of regional restoration

  • carrying out post-operation and post disturbances analysis, and

  • reporting and identifying regional electricity crisis scenarios

Ahead of their entering into operation by 1 July 2022, the geographical scope of the RCCs had to be defined through a proposal for system operation regions. 

The proposal had to be submitted to ACER by the European Network of Transmission System Operators for Electricity (ENTSO-E) and specify which transmission system operators, bidding zones, bidding zone borders, capacity calculation regions and outage coordination regions are covered by each of the system operation regions. 

The proposal had to take into account the grid topology, including the level of interconnection and interdependency of the electricity system in terms of flows and the size of the region (covering at least one capacity calculation region).

The activities of RCCs are coordinated across regional boundaries, while the day-to-day coordination within and between the RCCs is managed by cooperation processes among the transmission system operators of the region, as well as by arrangements between the RCCs.

​Action 1: From October to November 2019, ENTSO-E has conducted a public consultation on its proposal for System Operation Regions (SOR). ​

Action 2: On 6 January 2020, ENTSO-E submitted the SOR proposal to ACER. Find out more about the ENTSO-E proposal for System Operation Regions and the Explanatory document accompanying the proposal.

Action 3:  On 6 January 2020, ACER opened a public consultation for all stakeholders on ENTSO-E proposal.

Action 4:  Within three months following the receipt of the proposal, ACER had to approve or amend it. In case of any amendments, ACER should consult ENTSO-E before adopting any changes.

Action 5: ACER published the adopted proposal on its website.​

Action 6: On 15 March 2021, ACER published a public notice on the opening of a procedure for the definition of system operation regions​ (ACER-ELE-2021-010).

Action 7: On 29 June 2021, ACER published its Decision on the definition of system operation regions (Decision No 08/2021).

Action 8: On 19 October 2021, ACER withdrew Decision No 08/2021 and reopened the procedure for the definition of system operation regions.

Action 9: On 8 April 2022, ACER published the adopted decision (ACER Decision No 05/2022) on its website.

New Electricity Regulation

ACER’s monitoring of Regional Coordination Centres

Image
Electricity network

The revised ACER Regulation introduces new tasks for ACER in the regulatory oversight of Regional Coordination Centres (RCCs).

Specifically, ACER is responsible for monitoring and analysing the performance of RCCs in close cooperation with the national regulatory authorities (NRAs) and the European Network of Transmission System Operators for Electricity (ENTSO-E). To this end, ACER established a project group with the concerned stakeholders.

To monitor and analyse the performance of RCCs, ACER must take into account the reports submitted by each of them pursuant to their reporting obligations under the Electricity Regulation.

To carry out its monitoring tasks, ACER has to:

  • issue approvals for any new advisory tasks of the RCCs;
  • request information from RCCs where appropriate in the context of monitoring and reporting obligations of RCCs;
  • issue opinions and recommendations to the European Parliament, the Council and the Commission; and
  • issue opinions and recommendations to RCCs.

Monitoring plan

As of 2023, ACER is monitoring the regular reporting obligations of the RCCs and plans to deliver an annual report on the submissions made by each of them, in accordance with their reporting obligations under the Electricity Regulation.

In the future, ACER plans to additionally monitor the RCCs’ performance of their tasks and aims to deliver a more detailed report focused on one particular RCC task or an aspect of a task each year. A monitoring roadmap will be defined in due course.

ACER monitoring reports on RCCs' reporting obligations

New Electricity Regulation

Guaranteed cross-border capacity levels and temporary exemptions

Following the revision of the Electricity Regulation, Transmission System Operators (TSOs) have the obligation to reach a minimum level of cross-zonal capacity to facilitate electricity trading across countries.

When Member States or TSOs cannot comply with their obligations, they can establish an action plan, or ask for a derogation.

Derogations allow TSOs more time to implement the necessary measures and be compliant; and they are granted for a maximum of two years. Action plans provide time to address structural network constraints – possibly requiring investment – over a longer time horizon (5 years). National regulatory authorities can grant derogations, while action plans are provided by the Member State.

To facilitate the monitoring of the European electricity market, the Agency is compiling all the derogations and action plans granted and also collecting relevant documents.​

New Electricity Regulation

New rules on demand response

The Electricity Regulation envisages the development of European network codes in different areas, based on a priority list established by the European Commission every three years.

The latest priority list for the development of harmonised electricity rules for 2020-2023 period includes the rules on demand side flexibility - including rules on aggregation, energy storage and demand curtailment rules.

To seek a diversified expert advice on these topics, ACER has established a dedicated Expert Group on demand side flexibility.

On 21 October 2022, the European Commission invited ACER to carry out a scoping exercise for the coming Framework Guideline on this topic. ACER’s conclusions were delivered to the European Commission on 1 February 2022.

On 1 June 2022, the European Commission invited ACER to submit non-binding framework guidelines setting out clear and objective principles for the development of a network code on demand response. ACER ran a public consultation from 2 June to 12 August 2022. The resulting Framework Guideline on Demand Response was submitted to the European Commission on 20 December 2022.

The European Commission cleared ACER’s framework guideline in March 2023, and asked the DSO Entity and ENTSO-E to draft the proposal for the new binding EU rules. On 8 May 2024, ACER received electricity system operators’ proposal for an EU-wide network code on demand response. 

ACER ran a public consultation in autumn 2024 on the ACER-revised draft proposal. ACER organised a webinar during the consultation period, on 1 October 2024.

ACER submitted the final proposal to the European Commission on 7 March 2025. On 27 March 2025, ACER will hold a webinar to present its proposal on the new EU-wide network code on demand response.

Documents

See Also

Clean Energy Package

acer image

​​The Clean Energy for all Europeans Package is the latest update in the European energy policy framework, aiming to facilitate a clean energy transition and the implementation of the Energy Union strategy goals. It addresses five key dimensions:

  • Energy security

  • Internal energy market

  • Energy efficiency

  • Decarbonisation of the economy

  • Fostering research, innovation and competitiveness

Fostering a clean energy transition for all Europeans
Documents
See Also

​The Package, adopted during the course of 2019, consists of eight legislative acts as well as other initiatives and measures aimed at facilitating the clean energy transition. 

The Clean Energy Package lays the ground for establishing a new electricity market design by introducing an updated Electricity Directive and Regulation, a new Regulation on Risk Preparedness and a revised ACER Regulation.​

​The adoption of the Clean Energy for all Europeans Package introduced several changes to the system operations rulebook. 

The new rules, defined by the Electricity Regulation and Risk Preparedness Regulation, lay the ground for further improvements to the network codes, the introduction of a European Distribution System Operator (DSO) entity, the establishment of regional coordination centres, the implementation of system operation regions, as well as risk preparedness measures, fostering and enhancing the coordination of the European electricity market.​

acer image
A brief historic introduction
The main changes
See Also

Capacity mechanisms

acer image

​​​​A capacity mechanism is a temporary measure introduced by Member States to remunerate capacity resources (e.g. generators, demand-response or storage units) for security of supply services.

Capacity mechanisms can be introduced or maintained only if a resource adequacy concern has been identified, and should be open to cross-border participation.

The ACER-CEER Market Monitoring Reports​ includes topics related to security of supply, estimating the cost incurred for the capacity mechanisms in operation or under consideration. ​

What is it?
Related documents
See Also

Security of supply

A secure supply of electricity is crucial for the European Union. As electricity powers homes and businesses across Europe, consumers increasingly rely on its continuous availability.

Security of supply is one of the five mutually reinforcing dimensions of the Energy Union strategy. In responding to current challenges, the Energy Union facilitates energy market integration, which is essential for a stable supply.

At the core of the Energy Union

​ACER is committed to enable a high-level of security of supply in a cost efficient and non-discriminatory manner. 

Well-functioning wholesale markets contribute to this goal. However, regulatory distortions or other issues may prevent electricity prices from reflecting their true value when security of supply is at risk, possibly leading to underinvestment and security of supply issues.

In this case, additional measures may be needed to increase security of supply. Such measures can include removing regulatory distortions and introducing temporary capacity mechanisms.

Risk-preparedness also ensures that risks related to security of supply are identified in a timely and consistent manner, as well as they are properly monitored and mitigated.

What's the role of ACER?
See Also